RELO Roundtable…a gathering place

For folks who have stuff to move and the professionals who can help them

Senate investigates household goods carriers and move brokers

By • Dec 20th, 2011 • Category: Consumer Help, Consumer Protection, FMCSA, Hostage Load, MovingScams

Magnifying Glass(3) Senate investigates household goods carriers and move brokers  On Monday, Sen. John D. (Jay) Rockefeller, D-W.Va, chairman of the U.S. Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, announced that his Committee is conducting an investigation into the practice of moving companies holding household goods “hostage” to extract additional money from individuals and families mid-way through their moves.

According the committee press release, “thousands of consumers have complained in recent years about moving companies refusing to complete delivery until they pay exorbitant fees that were not part of the original estimates.”

“Consumers are telling us that ‘hostage’ scams are widespread and giving a bad name to the moving companies that try to act honestly,” Rockefeller said. “For this reason, we need to know just how bad this problem is and try once and for all to bring it to an end. When you hire a moving company you should not worry that your bed, couch and children’s possessions could end up stuck in a truck someplace while a moving company negotiates a higher payment.”

As part of the committee's investigation, Rockefeller asked two moving companies and two household goods move brokers licensed by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) to provide the Senate Commerce Committee with information about their business practices and why they have generated a significant number of consumer complaints related to “hostage” load scams.

Letters asking for very specific, detailed information regarding each company's sales and marketing programs, operational enforcement and compliance to Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) regulations explanation were sent to the owners and principles of Best Price Moving and Storage, Inc. (USDOT# 693651 ; MC# 321559), Nationwide Relocation Services (MC# 381766), Budget Van Lines (MC# 512534), and Able Moving, Inc (USDOT# 1418141; MC# 536623).

Judges Gavel Senate investigates household goods carriers and move brokers  Despite the inference in its name, Budget Van Lines, like Nationwide Relocation Services, is a licensed household goods and property move broker. During the last three years, both brokerage companies have sued the owner and moderators at MovingSCAM, a popular online consumer-oriented complaint forum where dissatisfied customers post comments about the poor quality of service they received during their interstate moves.

The Commerce Committee began its inquiry into “hostage” scams in October, 2011 when Chairman Rockefeller wrote FMCSA Administrator Ann Ferro asking her office to provide the number of consumer complaints the agency has received in recent years, documents related to FMCSA’s tracking of the problem, and current FMCSA resources devoted to combating hostage household goods load situations.

According the committee press release, the information provided by FMCSA showed that thousands of consumers have complained to the agency about this practice in recent years. “Hostage” scams, according to the committee, remain a significant threat for individuals and families undertaking interstate moves.

Related U.S. Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation Files:

Letter to Best Price Moving and Storage, Inc. – Letter to Mr. Adani 12.19.11.pdf (1.1 MBs)
Letter to Nationwide Relocation Services – Letter to Mr. DiSorbo 12.19.11.pdf (1.2 MBs)
Letter to Budget Van Lines – Letter to Mr. Katz 12.19.11.pdf (1.1 MBs)
Letter to Able Moving, Inc. – Letter to Mr. Mondell 12.19.11.pdf (1.1 MBs)
Letter to FMCSA – Letter to Administrator Ferro 10.3.11.pdf (1.0 MBs)

Related Articles:

Senate relies on industry pros to rout rogue movers – RELO Roundtable

Rockefeller Investigates Consumer Complaints of Moving Companies Holding Furniture & Possessions Hostage - Senate Press Office

Feds crack down on more rogue movers and brokers – RELO Roundtable

Another move broker, Budget Van Lines, sues MovingScam – RELO Roundtable

 


New Logo 150 x 40 Senate investigates household goods carriers and move brokers    is a mutually supportive but commercially neutral learning environment that deals with the trials and tribulations of movin’.

Have questions or need professional assistance with an upcoming moving and storage issue, or help choosing a domestic or international relocation product or service supplier?

FOLLOW US and SUBSCRIBE at:

Linkedin Icon(3) Senate investigates household goods carriers and move brokers    Facebook Icon(1) Senate investigates household goods carriers and move brokers    Twitter Icon(4) Senate investigates household goods carriers and move brokers   rss button(2) Senate investigates household goods carriers and move brokers   Email Icon(3) Senate investigates household goods carriers and move brokers

Tagged as: , , , , , , ,
  • Anonymous

    The problem isn’t the movers, the problem is customers not reading the paperwork that they agree to and just looking for the cheapest price. Honestly, they expect a mover to have 100 years in the business with an A+ rating, show up at 9am on the dot, have a truck made of gold and workers that have a masters degree in moving furniture AND they want the cheapest price…impossible!!! After the move is done they will swear up and down that they were never told about packing requirements, charges for flights of stairs or elevators and long carries and the foreman on the move date will show them on the paperwork that they reserved with where it covers those topics that they didn’t read. Customers do not understand for a moving company to go out and give a visual estimate for every customer that requests an estimate not only makes it so the mover can handle less customers, it also makes it so the mover has more overhead costs so then they have to raise the price to make any profit and they lose jobs because the customers go with the lowest price they can find. The only solution is to have the president go on national tv and tell people that if you are looking for a moving company, be sure to read all paperwork thorougly and do not go for the lowest price then maybe movers that work harder for the business will get the customers that they deserve. The thing about taking furniture hostage started because alot of movers do not unload until full payment is received and they do that because some customers try to be slick and say they see something damaged and refuse to pay so if the mover opens the door for delivery and the customer calls the police, the police will tell them to unload since they have opened the door to unload. If the mover did not open the door to unload, the police can’t do anything.

  • Anonymous

    And the problem is only going to get worse because honest movers that give honest estimates and spend more money to give a higher quality of service are going to get less customers and have to close their doors and in the meantime the scam movers that give the lowest price to get a job on the board and raise it up on the move date get to pay their bills and survive until their reputation gets too bad then they just start a new company.

  • Buck Freedman

    nice guy! hmmmm! Not really!

  • Buck Freedman

    Yes all of these companies should totally be investigated to be sure the GOOD AMERICAN PEOPLE ARE GETTING TREATED AS AMERICANS IN THE BEST WAY AND WITH LOVE AND RESPECT! I I KNOW NOW THAT IT IS WRONG TO NOT OFFER CUSTOMERS WHAT THEY WERE PROMISED!!! There are so many good moving companies in the country such as CONTINENTAL VAN LINES in Pompano beach florida, America Eagle Movers in Florida, Coast 2 Coast Vanalines inb Houston Texas, Moving America of Houston are all fine companies and they run business totally different… BAD COMPANIES MUST GET WHAT IS COMING TO THEM FOR SURE AND SOON THEY WILL HOPEFULLY STOP RIPPING OFF THE PUBLIC! If they are found ionnocent, let them be…IF THEY ARE FOUND GUILTY…HANG EM HIGH!!!. I SIMPLY WANT JUSTICE FOR THE GOOD AMERICAN PEOPLE!! I LOVE AMERICANS! I LOVE GOOD BUSINESS! I HATE BAD RIPP OFF COMPANIES HURTING OUR AMERICAN PEOPLE! PLEASE PUT A STOP TO THIS NOW!!!

  • Anonymous

     ”I KNOW NOW THAT IT IS WRONG TO NOT OFFER CUSTOMERS WHAT THEY WERE PROMISED!!”

    So what you where not doing it before.. till now  sound to me you are one of those “rouge” mover especially when you look into the other company coast 2 coast, moving America are the same company 

    Funny how you promote Continental van line another moving broker,

    American Eagle Movers Legal name The INCREDIBLE BULK MOVING COMPANY INC  ,and
    Coast 2 coast Legal name Moving America  
    Moving America legal name is Coast 2 coast

    All the company show only 1 truck and 1 Driver  registered with the FMCA

    also why the consent need to mention America and American people ? are you just praying on the good American’s patriotism ?? and why the need to do business under 3 different names ?  just sayin